England: Day Five (Interlude)





“I just don’t get this thing you have for old books,” said lots of people, always.

It’s okay. Of all my strange affections, this is possibly the one about which I feel the least embarrassment. I’ve always been bashful about my tendency to read books with dragons, or my weird fascination with honeybees, or basically everything in thrift stores, but I am and will remain an unapologetic bibliophile. But I get it. I get why you think I’m crazy. How in the world, you ask, will I have time to read all those books, and why in the world would I let them take over my house–especially when you can store all that information on a Kindle or a Nook or an iPad? What could possibly be enjoyable about rummaging around in a dusty bookshop for hours?

IMG_5007Let me explain, in bullet-point fashion for the sake of brevity.

— Old books smell good. Don’t believe me? According to a study by lead scientist Matija Strlicat at the Smithsonian, the chemical breakdown of old paper and binding creates “a combination of grassy notes with a tang of acids and a hint of vanilla over an underlying mustiness, [and] this unmistakable smell is as much a part of the book as its contents. One of my favorite things Pappy did when I showed him my finds was to open the book and thrust his nose into it, inhale deeply, and then sigh—as if this were as important a test of the book’s value as the publication date.

— A room full of books hearkens me back to my childhood—to vast public libraries, to my dad’s office at the church, and to the shelves of books at my house. A shelf of books is a shelf of possible worlds, possible adventures, possible discoveries, and it’s no exaggeration to say that I get the same feeling in an old library as I did when I was a kid in the family station wagon driving through the gates to Disney World. This sensation is heightened when I peruse the spines of books I have read and loved.

— Posterity. Because books will never be out of date—trust me on this; I enjoy my Nook and see the value in the eBook thing, but in 100 years actual books will be more valuable, not less—whenever I buy an old, beautiful copy of a book I love, I think of my future grandchildren and their children. They won’t have ever met me, but looking through these old fairy tales and books about Jesus and mystery and adventure will tell them something about what I believed to be important—or at least what geeked me out. Pappy and I visited the Bodleian Library in Oxford and beheld shelves of 500-year-old books. They weren’t in a glass case. They were readable copies. No, the actual hold-it-in-your-hand, thrust-in-your-nose-and-inhale book isn’t going anywhere, my electronics loving friend.

— Preservation. There are a limited number of first editions of The Great Divorce left in the world, and that number is actually getting smaller. In a book about Hay-on-Wye called Sixpence House (Paul Collins, 2003) he tells about the piles and piles of books that get shipped to this book town and never get sold, so sometimes they throw them outside where they’re eventually burned. BURNED. I shudder to think of the treasures that were inadvertently tossed out. But we can still buy new editions of The Great Divorce, you say. True. But they don’t smell good. Neither does the actual artifact represent sixty years of travel from owner to owner. Neither do you get the mild thrill of knowing that when C. S. Lewis opened his parcel from the publisher and first saw his new book in its completed form, this is what he held in his hands. Not only that, I like to wonder who was this person who happened to buy, during its first week of sale, what would become a classic in fifty years?

— Old books are beautiful. Not all old books, but many, especially in the Victorian era. My early editions of George MacDonald books are works of art, which doubles the pleasure when the story inside is beautiful, too. It’s like a literary Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup.

— This is a bit more mercenary, but it’s also a financial thing. While it’s thrilling to find a rare book at a rare book shop, it’s far more thrilling to find a rare book at Goodwill. And it happens. My favorite bookshops are the rambly ones, the ones with piles of books on the floor, with the books ever-so-slightly out of order, because you stand a better chance of happening upon something awesome for mere pennies. It’s the booksellers who know their business that tend to be overpricing killjoys. If I can pay four bucks for an old Annie Dillard book that I already own, I can sell it later for twice or thrice as much, or give it as a gift (don’t old books make the best gifts?) that’s worth far more than a $20 gift card to Starbucks. Perhaps my most valuable discovery was in one of those rambly old bookstores in Texas. It was an early edition (not a first) of J. M. Barrie’s biography of his mother. I’m not a huge Barrie fan (I’ve never read Peter Pan, but I did love Finding Neverland), but the spine was attractive so I pulled it out and thumbed through it. I was surprised to discover that it was autographed by Barrie himself. This little book in Texas had been held by the man who thought up Peter Pan a hundred years ago. It cost me $6. When I got home I looked it up and found similar signed copies for sale for $800. Now, if only I could happen upon a cheap first edition of The Great Divorce (which I’ve never laid eyes on), then I’d be happy. Right?

So it was with giddy anticipation that Pappy and I drove the two hours through hedgerows and little villages to the border of Wales and England, where the town of Hay (and its 25 or so used bookshops) rests on the River Wye, beckoning to book lovers all over the world.

It was also the first time in our trip that I wanted to throttle dear Pappy.

(To be continued…)


This is a shot of Hay-on-Wye, from Hay Castle. Yes, those are books under the awning, and yes, you can see three of the fabled bookshops along the street in this one picture. The place is wonderful.


[Day One]
[Day Two]
[Day Three]
[Day Four]

Eric Peters, affectionately called "Pappy" by those who love him, is the grand old curmudgeon of the Rabbit Room. But his small stature and often quiet presence belie a giant talent. He's a songwriter of the first order, and a catalogue of great records bears witness to it. His last album, Birds of Relocation, blew minds and found its way onto “year’s best” lists all over the country. When he's not painting, trolling bookstores, or dabbling in photography, he's touring the country in support of his latest record, Far Side of the Sea.


  1. Dan Rechlin

    I like the fact that the oldest single thing in my small apartment (by a long shot; older than the building even) is a first American printing of Brideshead Revisited, which I picked up from a mousey fellow somewhere along the line. You might be a budding bibliophile if…

  2. LauraP

    This made me go to my bookshelf to sniff my first (American) edition of “The Great Divorce”, which I purchased from The Book Mole, aka, dear Pappy.

    Mmmmmm. 😉

  3. whipple

    I will forever direct my tech-geek, non-tactile, and – *ahem – Philistine friends to this worthy explanation of why books are important. Good trees should not die only to become subpoenas and two-foot Kroger receipts.

  4. Kathy

    I have conceived an ambition as of four minutes ago to stay long enough in the vicinity of this particular town to browse each store, if not each shelf.
    And let it be so.

  5. Karoline

    I agree with all your bibliophile-ness. I just was given 6 file boxes full of old books, and my brother says, “You have too many books — you’re never going to read all these!” Ah, but I might, and even if I don’t, there is history in those pages. I love seeing what people wrote in the front covers of their books in 1902, and I wonder who they were. And yes, the first thing I did to the first book I pulled out of the box was gently open it, stick my nose inside, and inhale deeply. Who cares if my family thinks I’m weird?! 🙂

  6. Kristen

    I love this. Last year I was perusing the dusty shelves at the local used bookshop and happened upon an old edition of A Diary of Private Prayer by John Baillie. I had purchased a copy shortly after reading about it here at The Rabbit Room, but that didn’t matter. I picked the book up, inhaled its musty scent, and read the inscription dated 1967. I recognized the handwriting. And the name of the giver. My grandma had given this book to a friend all those years ago, and 18 years after she died, I found it in my local bookshop. That will never happen with a Kindle book.

  7. Lisa

    Wow, Kristen. Chills.

    The smell of old books. Yes. One of my favourite things to do in University was to scuttle down to the old library which was in the basement of one of the older buildings on campus. It wasn’t a romantic, wooden shelf type library, and it housed mainly scholarly papers, etc. But I loved the maze of shelves crammed with old books on obscure topics, and often would get distracted in my search for the particular paper I was looking for when I spotted something else. I’m sure all those old papers are online now, and the Cameron Library at the University of Alberta might not even be there anymore, I don’t know. Which makes me sad for current students. It’s just not the same.

  8. Peggy Dailey

    I work at Goddwill; find bargains all the time. My best was from the local friends of the library for a dollar i got an autographed copy of Families by Wyatt cooper. Gloria Wanderbilt’s hubanda and Anderson’s dad woith a quote a sketch and his hometown obit pasted in. I sold it for $485 to a private collector., This was a great article. Id lov to visit Haye on Wye.–Peggy

If you have a Rabbit Room account, log in here to comment.