Tuning Up: A Few Words About the Forums


Now that the new site has been up and running for a week, I thought I’d take a few minutes to address some questions that have come up.

Let me start by taking a time-warp to 2007. Back in the days of yore there was a thriving message board (or forum) on the Andrew Peterson website. It was affectionately called “Andyland” by those who hung out there, and it was filled with a loyal bunch of Andrew’s fans who enjoyed a vibrant conversation via the website.

When we launched the Rabbit Room, the decision was made to shut down that message board and direct those conversations to the Rabbit Room comments section, where we hoped to provide a more defined area for discussion via blog posts. There were a few folks who didn’t care for the change and moved their attentions elsewhere, but most folks rolled with it, and it wasn’t long before the conversation was a lot bigger than it had been before. Soon there were more than just Andrew Peterson fans involved. Jason Gray fans added their voices, and Andy Gullahorn fans, and Eric Peters fans, and Wendell Berry fans, and pretty soon that word, “fan,” began to drop away. What we had instead were folks who enjoyed the Rabbit Room itself and it’s general focus on art, music, and story—which was the point all along.

That group of folks grew and ultimately called for Hutchmoot, they wanted to incarnate the Rabbit Room in flesh and blood, and in 2010 we made it happen. People came and met one another and formed real relationships (marriages even) that are still growing and maturing today.

But somewhere along the way there was a bump in the road. It didn’t feel like a bump at the time, it felt like pure fun and excitement, but years later we’ve begun to realize that the bump knocked a wheel off the cart.

Let me explain.

On a whim, Thomas McKenzie created a private group on Facebook so we’d have a handy place to pass along information and Hutchmoot alums could easily find one another and stay in touch. No problem. That’s awesome.

But here’s what happened over time:

  1. Initially, we didn’t pay attention to who we invited into the group. All were welcome.
  2. Folks got to know one another, people came out of their shells, community thrived, people shared and opened themselves up in personal ways, and tight bonds formed.
  3. Then people began to be concerned that a few folks in the group hadn’t been to Hutchmoot and therefore didn’t understand the tone, or intent, or the one-on-one connections that others had made in person. There was disruption and there were a few hurt feelings.
  4. We decided to stop admitting folks to the group unless they had attended Hutchmoot or had purchased a ticket.
  5. That seemed to solve the issue brought up in #3. Those who were in the group enjoyed one another’s company freely and all was well again. Right?

That brings us to 2016. Over the last couple of years, we’ve watched as the vibrant discussions of the Rabbit Room have slowly moved away from the site itself, not just to Facebook, but largely to a private, members-only group on Facebook. What began as a way to include people and foster community, had become a means of excluding people and fostering an inner circle in which some were welcome and those on the outside were left oblivious or frustrated. For an organization whose mission is to foster community, the wheels were coming off the axles.

Now that doesn’t mean the Facebook group was a bad thing. It wasn’t/isn’t. It’s a great thing, but it was having unintended consequences, those consequences were large enough to endanger the long-term health of the community it was created to serve.

So we’re upgrading those wheels to fresh new radial tires and putting them back on the cart where they belong. Here’s how:

  1. The Hutchmoot group on Facebook will remain. It’s there for the alumni of Hutchmoot and the Rabbit Room Retreat. It’s intended to be a place to stay in touch and pass along information related to those events. Content that strays far from that purpose will be gently redirected.
  2. We’ve added a private Hutchmoot/Retreat Alumni forum here on the Rabbit Room website. Anyone who has been to one of those events can request (and will be granted) access. This will be adhered to militantly so that we can know the folks engaged in conversation within the forum will all have a solid understanding of the in-person and inter-personal nature of Hutchmoot and the retreat. But—no longer should general conversation take place in this closed circle. Topics that ought to be available to the wider community, ought to take place in the common area of the forums.
  3. The Rabbit Room Forums are available to everyone. This means that those discussions of art and music and story that were once available only to a few, can now be enjoyed and engaged by everyone in the Rabbit Room community. We aren’t interested in creating cliques—we’re interested in creating community.

But wait, some may say, I don’t know what a forum is. It looks complicated. I don’t think I can do that. Let me point out first that it’s significantly simpler than the interface pictured below.

Screen Shot 2016-06-05 at 10.59.39 AM

Sure, we all know how to use Facebook today, but that’s because we’ve forgotten our first baffling interactions with its complex set of functions, divisions, and conversations.

The Rabbit Room isn’t trying to replace Facebook, of course, but we want to provide a healthy place for a more focused set of conversations.

Having said that, yes, there are still bugs to work out, features to implement, and tweaks to make in order to better realize what’s already there. Like anything new, it’s going to grow and change and evolve. Does it look to some like an overload of information? Almost certainly. But, as Rebecca Reynolds points out here, there’s no need to take it all in, any more than you have to participate in every single conversation when you go to a social gathering at a friends house.

This is a room. And it shouldn’t be a locked room. You’re invited to come inside. As conversations begin to take place and draw more voices, the forums are the best way to help people find the topics (and other voices) that suit them best. We’ve always been committed to maintaining a place for measured and gracious conversation, and that won’t change. The forum moderators are there to pay attention to what’s going on and to ensure that things remain safe and civil—just as has always been the case.

To those who were part of the “inner circle” and are feeling a little like someone has just kicked in the door, consider this: The Rabbit Room is made up of thousands of people from all over the world, and all of those folks have something beautiful to add to the community. It’s time we set them a place at the table.

To everyone, come in and be welcome. There’s room for you here.


Pete Peterson is the author of the Revolutionary War adventure The Fiddler’s Gun and its sequel Fiddler’s Green. Among the many strange things he’s been in life are the following: U.S Marine air traffic controller, television editor, art teacher and boatwright at the Florida Sheriffs Boys Ranch, and progenitor of the mysterious Budge-Nuzzard. He lives in Nashville with his wife, Jennifer, where he's the Executive Director of the Rabbit Room and Managing Editor of Rabbit Room Press.


  1. Chris Yokel


    And if you’re feeling like learning the new forums is like trying to ride a bike for the first time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eaIvk1cSyG8

  2. Lisa Smith

    As one who has never been to Hutchmoot but would dearly love to, thanks so much for opening the door. Maybe one day I will be fortunate enough to get there, but for now I’m excited to get the chance to listen in on some of the conversations and maybe even contribute a bit.

  3. Sara Masarik

    As someone who is new to Rabbit Room this year, but who is quickly finding so much richness here, I am deeply grateful for this move. As someone who is trying to moderate a massive (1,100 person) online book club, I am deeply grateful to learn from your wisdom and experience. Thank you for this explanation. I am one of your new members who delights in feeling welcome. 


  4. Lisa Eldred


    Unrelatedly, it makes me happy that @stephenhesselman‘s toddler’s destructive rampage is featured in this post.

    …and if the switch from the Facebook group to the forum means meeting more people like the Hesselmans, well, I suppose that can only be a good thing.

  5. Rebecca D. Martin

    I love how y’all have thought through this. I’m put in mind of C.S. Lewis’s essays “The Inner Ring” and “Membership.” Really life-bearing – and thoughtful and kind.

  6. Stephen Hesselman


    Amen… I’ve been so grateful for being welcomed by this group, and it makes me glad that welcoming others is a significant focus of the Rabbit Room. That’s the way I want to live too.

    And @firstcrusader, that’s so nice… thanks! We’re super happy we know you, too! I think Pete used that screenshot by default… is there actually anyone on Facebook that posts MORE than I do? 🙂

  7. Chris Whitler


    “Ah, there it is, there it is, Chief,” cried all the others. “There’s the point. No one’s got a clearer head than you. You couldn’t have made it plainer.”

  8. Kathleen Mahoney


    This is simply beautiful. Thank you so much for this @pete. And thank you also for the history of how Rabbits creating a room all began 😀 I look forward to interacting more and going from someone a little on the outskirts to someone plopping down at the table a taking a bite 😀

  9. Laure Hittle


    i am grateful,
    so, so grateful

    for this place and for you people and for you, @pete. Thank you (and @andrew and the board) for your militant hospitality. For seeing dangers to our health as a community and pouring yourself into addressing those dangers. For fighting to protect us from being smaller than we were meant to be and from feeling small when the change is hard. For modeling welcome and welcoming us into welcoming each other.

    This invitation into deeper community is an unfathomable gift. i love saying us. It still feels too good to be true, but it is true. This is home and i belong, and because i belong i can also run to meet those who come.

  10. Bethany Winz


    Thank you for flinging the doors wide and helping every single one of us feel welcome. And thank you for the tireless work you and so many others have put into the new site and the forums and everything else that is The Rabbit Room. I’m more grateful than I can say for this place, and I can’t wait to see all that it continues to become.

  11. Karoline

    Ditto to Bethany’s comment. I love the new forum feature… About a year ago, I thought to myself that it would be awesome if RR created forums, and lo! Thank you for everything you guys do, and for giving thought to those of us who have wondered how to become more included. 🙂

If you have a Rabbit Room account, log in here to comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.